Compare the Best Electricity Rates and Suppliers in Butler
We analyze, rank, and recommend the best plans from the highest rated providers in Butler.
Recommended Electricity and Natural Gas Plans in Butler
Recommended
Electric 12 Month Fixed Rate WITH MRC
- 12
- monthsmo.
- Fixed Rate
- 0% Green Energy
- Plan MRCMRC
- $ 14.95
Recommended
Clean Power 12
- 12
- monthsmo.
- Fixed Rate
- 100% Green Energy
- Plan MRCMRC
- $ 0
Recommended
Safe Harbor Value 9
- 9
- monthsmo.
- Fixed Rate
- 0% Green Energy
- Plan MRCMRC
- $ 0
Recommended
12 Month Green Home Power Plan
- 12
- monthsmo.
- Fixed Rate
- 0% Green Energy
- Plan MRCMRC
- $ 0
Recommended
SureLock 12
- 12
- monthsmo.
- Fixed Rate
- 0% Green Energy
- Plan MRCMRC
- $ 0
Recommended
Fixed-Rate Gas 12
- 12
- monthsmo.
- Fixed Rate
- 0% Green Energy
- Plan MRCMRC
- $ 0
Recommended
Fixed rate 12
- 12
- monthsmo.
- Fixed Rate
- 0% Green Energy
- Plan MRCMRC
- $ 0
Average Natural Gas Rates & Usage in Butler
In November, the average natural gas rate in Butler was $1.65 per therm. The average households monthly natural gas usage was 124 therms, making the average bill around $153.
based on EIA Data as of September, 2025
Butler Energy Choice
You can choose your electricity or natural gas retailer in Butler. We're here to help you navigate the sometimes daunting array offers and providers. As a neutral third party we provide you with the tools to make the best choice for your home energy needs.
To help you with this choice, you may browse the best electricity and natural gas companies in Butler, or read Butler energy company reviews. If you would rather go directly to comparing plans, you may view all Butler electricity plans, or compare the best natural gas plans in Butler .
Video: What is the Best Electricity Rate in Butler - for Fall 2025
All Electricity and Natural Gas Plans in Butler
True Classic 12
- 0% Green Energy
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 12 months from now in October of 2026.Since this plan expires in October, you can take advantage of seasonally lower rates when you renew.
- Monthly Recurring Charge: $14
- fixed-rate
- 12 Months
Residential Clean Energy Plan
- 25% Green Energy
Our assessment:
- variable-rate
- 1 Month
Online Broker October 2025 Intro Rate
- 0% Green Energy
Our assessment:
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 2 months from now in December of 2025.Since this plan expires in December, you can take advantage of seasonally lower rates when you renew.
- variable-rate
- 2 Months
Electric 12 Month Fixed Rate WITH MRC
- 0% Green Energy
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 12 months from now in October of 2026.Since this plan expires in October, you can take advantage of seasonally lower rates when you renew.
- Early Termination Fee: $50
- Monthly Recurring Charge: $14.95
- fixed-rate
- 12 Months
SureLock 6
- 0% Green Energy
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 6 months from now in April of 2026.Since this plan expires in April, you can take advantage of seasonally lower rates when you renew.
- Early Termination Fee: $55.00
- fixed-rate
- 6 Months
SureLock 12
- 0% Green Energy
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 12 months from now in October of 2026.Since this plan expires in October, you can take advantage of seasonally lower rates when you renew.
- Early Termination Fee: $110.00
- fixed-rate
- 12 Months
Live Brighter 12
- NEW CUSTOMERS ONLY!
- 0% Green Energy
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 12 months from now in October of 2026.Since this plan expires in October, you can take advantage of seasonally lower rates when you renew.
- fixed-rate
- 12 Months
Plan Details
NEW CUSTOMERS ONLY!
SimpleClean 12
- 50% Green Energy
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 12 months from now in October of 2026.Since this plan expires in October, you can take advantage of seasonally lower rates when you renew.
- Early Termination Fee: $110.00
- fixed-rate
- 12 Months
Safe Harbor Value 9
- 0% Green Energy
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 9 months from now in July of 2026.You might consider a different length plan, because this plan will expire in July when rates are seasonally higher.
- fixed-rate
- 9 Months
True Simple 6
- 0% Green Energy
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 6 months from now in April of 2026.Since this plan expires in April, you can take advantage of seasonally lower rates when you renew.
- fixed-rate
- 6 Months
Residential Clean Gas Plan
- 100% Green Energy
- estimate for 1000 kWh usage
Our assessment:
- variable-rate
- 1 Month
Flex Gas Choice Plan
- Digital Affiliate - 3 Mo Variable, No Frills
- 100% Green Energy
- estimate for 1000 kWh usage
Our assessment:
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 3 months from now in January of 2026.You might consider a different length plan, because this plan will expire in January when rates are seasonally higher.
- variable-rate
- 3 Months
Plan Details
SureLock 12
- 100% Green Energy
- estimate for 1000 kWh usage
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 12 months from now in October of 2026.You might consider a different length plan, because this plan will expire in October when rates are seasonally higher.
- Early Termination Fee: $110.00
- fixed-rate
- 12 Months
RescueLock 12
- 100% Green Energy
- estimate for 1000 kWh usage
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 12 months from now in October of 2026.You might consider a different length plan, because this plan will expire in October when rates are seasonally higher.
- Early Termination Fee: $110.00
- fixed-rate
- 12 Months
SureLock 24
- 100% Green Energy
- estimate for 1000 kWh usage
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 24 months from now in October of 2027.You might consider a different length plan, because this plan will expire in October when rates are seasonally higher.
- Early Termination Fee: $200.00
- fixed-rate
- 24 Months
Fixed-Rate Gas 12
- 100% Green Energy
- estimate for 1000 kWh usage
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 12 months from now in October of 2026.You might consider a different length plan, because this plan will expire in October when rates are seasonally higher.
- Early Termination Fee: $120
- fixed-rate
- 12 Months
Fixed rate 12
- 100% Green Energy
- estimate for 1000 kWh usage
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 12 months from now in October of 2026.You might consider a different length plan, because this plan will expire in October when rates are seasonally higher.
- Early Termination Fee: $0.0
- fixed-rate
- 12 Months
Fixed rate 24
- 100% Green Energy
- estimate for 1000 kWh usage
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 24 months from now in October of 2027.You might consider a different length plan, because this plan will expire in October when rates are seasonally higher.
- Early Termination Fee: $0.0
- fixed-rate
- 24 Months
Fixed rate 5
- 100% Green Energy
- estimate for 1000 kWh usage
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 5 months from now in March of 2026.Since this plan expires in March, you can take advantage of seasonally lower rates when you renew.
- Early Termination Fee: $50.0
- fixed-rate
- 5 Months
Live Brighter 18
- NEW CUSTOMERS ONLY!
- 100% Green Energy
- estimate for 1000 kWh usage
Our assessment:
This is a "No Gimmicks" Fixed Rate plan which means you have a consistent energy charge per kWh no matter how much (or little) enegy you use.
You will have more predictable bill based solely on your usage.
Plan Renewal:
If you order this plan and start it today, you will be up for renewal 18 months from now in April of 2027.Since this plan expires in April, you can take advantage of seasonally lower rates when you renew.
- fixed-rate
- 18 Months
Plan Details
NEW CUSTOMERS ONLY!
So far, so good. My first bill from them I saved $35.